Rating: ★★★
People of the Lake is about a girl who spends the summer with her dad in his hometown. It’s a quiet little town on Redmarch Lake, except the people there are weird. They don’t like outsiders. They don’t talk to outsiders. And they are definitely hiding something.
One night, after a party in the woods, a teenage boy washes up dead on the lakeshore, and the following morning a note shows up from Clara’s twin sister, written in a secret language they shared as twins. The only problem? Clara’s sister Zoe has been dead for eight years.
This book was slow to get going. It lingers a lot on unnecessary details. Clara’s inner monologue is often repetitive, as is the recounting of her mornings at the coffee shop. The dialogue often felt stiff and cliched. It isn’t bad per se, but it’s not really good either.
I also struggled with the way Clara was written. She was written very much how I think adults believe teenage girls are, rather than how they actually are. She was never fully realized as a person outside of her teenage girl-dom. There were a lot of tropes and cliches stuffed in that just came across as dated. (A step dad she doesn’t want to know, the weird unfriendly goth girl, the awkward Dad… the list goes on.)
That said, I did enjoy the plot. A lot of the details were held back until the end, keeping me in suspense. Even when I struggled, I wanted to see where the crazy train was taking me. There’s a silly romance shoehorned in at the end that you’ll see coming a mile away. By the time they got to “I love you’s” I was rolling my eyes.
There’s some odd pieces of history going back to the 1400s thrown in, that don’t feel like they ever culminate into anything. They reveal bits and pieces of the town’s history but don’t actually contribute to the overall story beyond what the character’s tell us (and what the character’s tell us is much more coherent).
The spook factor was decent. I loved the imagery of lights in the woods and the howling, accompanied by the ever present lake, so silent and still. It’s definitely supernatural in nature, as a heads up, if that kind of horror is not your thing.
I think this could have actually been great if there had been some stronger editing to get rid of the tropes and repetitiveness, and maybe been trimmed down to a novella size to keep the pace up. Thank you to the publisher and Edelweiss who provided an eARC for review.
People of the Lake released on October 15, 2019 and can be found on GoodReads or Amazon.
The set up sure sounds like a good one, but it’s too bad the rest of it didn’t live up to its potential. And yeah, I think it’s easy to fall into the trap of cliches, I think it’s the sign of an inexperienced writer.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes I thought the same thing- though I feel like I did look him up and he has written other things (could be wrong). Maybe it was his first stab at writing a teenage girl?
LikeLike
This sounded fun but I am going to skip based on this review. The cover is awesome though.
x The Captain
LikeLiked by 1 person
You aren’t missing anything!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I am so sorry you were disappointed with this one, Sarah! ☹️☹️ It really does suck when the plot could have actually gone somewhere great but the writing is horrible! ☹️☹️UGH! I HATE THAT! But heyyy, your review was VERYYY INFORMATIVE AND VERY WELL WRITTEN! ❤️❤️ I LOVED IT! ❤️❤️💕💕💕👻👻
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you!! It does kind of stink but I’m hoping the next read will be better.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I hope so toooooo!! ❤️
LikeLiked by 1 person
Sounds like a pretty average read. I get how it’s disappointing when you can see the potential there and it just relies on the same old things. Hopefully your next read will be better. 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
It wasn’t even bad- it wasn’t painful to read, but pretty average is a good way to describe it!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I do get so annoyed at the “how adults think teenagers are” thing. I don’t know that I’d do any better a job of it, but sometimes it seems like authors aren’t even trying. (I don’t know if that’s the case here, just drawing on my experience with other books.)
I love that cover, though. It somehow seems to evoke both the woods and underwater. Really cool.
LikeLiked by 1 person
The setting was great and sufficiently spooky and well written, it really was mostly the characterization I suffered.
I especially seem to notice it when it’s a man writing a teenage girl, I notice less with adult women, after all, they were teenagers once, (though I’m not saying adult women are immune). I just think when it’s a man it’s particularly noticeable, unfortunately. Maybe an unfair judgement, but that’s what I feel!
LikeLike
Well, that’s good! I’m glad the setting was enjoyable.
I suspect a lot of the problem is that the teenage experience is (or at least seems) more different based on gender than the adult experience. I mean, as adults there are gender differences too, but a lot of what we are focused on — job, money, etc — translates better. I can’t even start to begin thinking about how I’d write a teenage boy. How much of what I think they go through is a stereotype instead of real? Add that gender gap to the age gap, and it’s probably more rare to get a well-written teenager.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Exactly! Being a teen even 10 years ago was not the same as being a teen today to compound the problem.
LikeLike
The premise sounds very interesting, but the execution seems to need some work – or maybe a lot…
One of the things I believe would annoy me is the portrayal of young people through the use of clichés: to me it speaks of poor research…
Thanks for sharing! 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yeah that was the thing that stuck out to me most too. I think there was a good story hidden in there but as you said, execution needed work!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I like the sound of the plot, especially the note from a long-dead twin. But the silly tropes/stereotypes and the, by the sounds of the coffee mornings, padding out of the word count puts me off
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yeah- it might have been a decent, or at least forgivable novella. I find myself less annoyed with such things when I’m only subjected for a little while. Lol
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m currently midway through a novella. Had to put it down for a break to read something else. Its a real struggle to take seriously
LikeLiked by 1 person
Oh that’s a bummer. DNF it! I have a novel like that I’m “reading” now. I keep finding excuses to read something else.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I made a promise to myself to not DNF anything 😭
LikeLiked by 1 person
Eesh. Good luck then!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Oh man, I feel like it has way too many issues for me to ever really fully appreciate. I’m glad it wasn’t a complete waste of time though. The repetitiveness and the romance are what sounds especially heavy though. Great honest review, Sarah!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks Lashaan! Unfortunately it did have a few issues that I don’t think anyone likes to see these days.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Pingback: Month in Review: October 2019 | Hamlets & Hyperspace