Blurb (from GoodReads): A race of warrior angels, the Ben-Elim, once vanquished a mighty demon horde. Now they rule the Banished lands, but their peace is brutally enforced.
In the south, hotheaded Riv is desperate to join the Ben-Elim’s peacekeeping force, until she unearths a deadly secret.
In the west, the giantess Sig investigates demon sightings and discovers signs of an uprising and black magic.
And in the snowbound north, Drem, a trapper, finds mutilated corpses in the forests. The work of a predator, or something far darker?
It’s a time of shifting loyalties and world-changing dangers. Difficult choices need to be made. Because in the shadows, demons are gathering, waiting for their time to rise…
I picked this up because I’ve been meaning to read Gwynne for awhile. I meant to start with the first book set in this world: Malice, but I was trying to decide whether I wanted to request the third book in this series for review. One of my GoodReads buddies told me I really should have started with Malice in order to fully appreciate this book.
But I’m not really sure it would have helped any. When I first started reading, I was very happy. We started with a battle and lots of action, the characters felt unique and fun, the pacing and chapter length were perfect for me.
However, the novelty wore off relatively quickly. The action slows down after those initial few chapters, and Gwynne’s writing style isn’t one that necessarily agrees with me. For starters, I should mention the reason I’ve dragged my feet on this one for so long: angels and demons have never really been my thing. I find the black and white line of “good” and “evil” between them superficial and incredibly boring. I like my villains with a soft side and my heroes with shades of gray.
To be fair to Gwynne, his angels, or Ben-Elim, aren’t necessarily pure of heart. They don’t preach endless forgiveness and do react with extreme cruelty to “lore-breakers”. But then, evangelism really sort of irritates me too. And the demons are exactly as one note as you would expect.
I did enjoy some of the characters, namely Drem and Sig. Riv and Bleda’s storylines felt extremely YA to me- the warrior training, the lore learning, petty rivalries, and of course, the stupid love triangle. I feel like there might be a fifth perspective I’m missing, and that sure does say a lot doesn’t it? Considering I only finished a week ago.
Gwynne’s writing isn’t bad, and my issue with it comes strictly from a personal preference. The characters all have inner monologues, which we are told, and which are italicized. I know it’s not the first time I’ve seen inner monologues written down, however, here, for some reason they felt highly unnecessary and broke the flow of the writing. Worse still, they seemed to become more frequent as the book went on. I just didn’t like it.
What I did like about this book, aside from the angels and demons, was that the world-building is a lot of fun. There are different tribes and regions, giants riding bears, magical swords, rich histories… And Gwynne more or less delivers it without it feeling info dump-y. Newcomers to Gwynne can easily pick up this book and read it as if it was first book set in this world, even if returning fans might appreciate it a little more.
There are some gut wrenching emotional moments, so he succeeded in making me care at least. I am still undecided as to whether I will continue the series. I borrowed book two alongside book one, and with my local libraries closed, I’m able to keep it much longer than expected, so I might. I don’t think I’ll be requesting the ARC because I want to be free to leave these books behind if book two doesn’t agree with me.
I know this series is well loved by many, and it’s entirely possible that I wasn’t in the right mood to read this, so take my review with a grain of salt. A Time of Dread can be found on GoodReads if you’d like to check it out for yourself.
Have you read A Time of Dread? What did you think?